Try CPA TBS practice free of charge with this original receivables case and three complete answer keys. Rebuild customer balances, separate a write-off from an estimate, and correct the ledger without recording the same event twice. You can attempt the case directly with a calculator and a blank working page.

Start CPA TBS practice free of registration
This case tests allowance accounting through a transaction history, an actual posting error, and an independent recovery alternative. Difficulty is intermediate application. Before each reveal, write the requested balances and debit-credit entries. Keep your first response so you can identify the earliest wrong account rather than merely recognizing the final number.
No purchase, trial enrollment, account, or downloaded question file is needed for these exercises. All Nerlin facts, tasks, calculations, and explanations are original teaching material, not official, recalled, or retired exam content. The page provides useful practice with exhibits; it does not claim to reproduce the exam driver or its scoring.
First distinguish three quantities: gross receivables, the allowance balance, and current-period expense. The customer ledger tracks amounts owed. The allowance reduces that gross asset to its net carrying amount. Expense is a period movement, so it need not equal either the closing allowance or the cash recovered from an old account.
Read the original Nerlin receivables exhibits
Exhibit A: opening balances and scope
Nerlin Supply begins Year 1 with $160,000 gross Accounts Receivable and a $10,000 credit Allowance for Doubtful Accounts. Opening balances are correct. Use the allowance method and dollars throughout. There are no returns, discounts, taxes, foreign-exchange effects, or other receivable movements. Current-year bad-debt expense starts at zero.
The recovered account below was written off before Year 1 and is absent from opening gross receivables. It is separate from the current $8,000 write-off. Ordinary customer collections exclude the recovery receipt. These boundaries prevent you from subtracting one customer twice or including the same cash in two collection totals.
Exhibit B: actual current-year postings
| Event | Amount | Actual recorded treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Credit sales | $420,000 | Debit Accounts Receivable; credit Sales. |
| Ordinary collections | $365,000 | Debit Cash; credit Accounts Receivable. |
| Current-year write-off | $8,000 | Debit Bad-Debt Expense; credit Accounts Receivable. |
| Prior-year account recovery | $2,000 | First debit Accounts Receivable and credit Allowance. Then debit Cash and credit Accounts Receivable. |
Exhibit C: closing target and requested work
A completed year-end analysis requires a $17,000 closing credit allowance. Treat that result as a supplied estimate, not a rate you must derive. Nerlin has not posted its year-end estimate, and income accounts remain open. The write-off debit in Exhibit B is the only incorrect transaction posting; all other entries there are correct.
For Task 1, reconstruct correct gross receivables and the correct allowance before the estimate. Then calculate the required estimate expense. Task 2 asks you to repair the actual ledger and prove final expense and net receivables. Finally, Task 3 independently removes the recovery while retaining the same closing target.
CPA TBS practice free: rebuild the allowance
Start with gross receivables. Add credit sales to the opening customer balance and subtract ordinary collections and the current write-off. Then show both recovery entries separately. The reinstatement temporarily restores a customer balance, while collection removes it again. Consequently, those two entries have no combined effect on closing gross receivables.
Next reconstruct the allowance as though the write-off had used the correct account. Under the supplied allowance method, a write-off debits the allowance rather than a new expense. In contrast, reinstating the old account credits the allowance. Keep each direction visible before comparing the reconstructed balance with Exhibit C’s target.
Commit three outputs before revealing: closing gross receivables, the correct pre-estimate allowance with its debit or credit label, and the estimate expense needed. Do not use the actual incorrect allowance balance for this task. You are first building the correct transaction history so that the later repair has a reliable destination.
Check the correct transaction history
Commit gross receivables, the correct pre-estimate allowance, and required estimate expense.
Reveal the answer
Answer: Closing gross receivables are $207,000: $160,000 plus $420,000 less $365,000 less $8,000 plus $2,000 reinstated less $2,000 collected. The correct pre-estimate allowance is $4,000 credit: $10,000 less $8,000 plus $2,000. Debit Bad-Debt Expense and credit Allowance $13,000 to reach the required $17,000 ending credit.
The recovery entries cancel in gross receivables, but reinstatement adds a $2,000 allowance credit. A correct write-off uses an $8,000 allowance debit rather than another expense. Therefore, the remaining credit needed is $17,000 minus $4,000. Using the opening allowance unchanged or treating the closing target as the expense ignores the current transaction history.
CPA TBS practice free: repair the posted entry
Now return to what the bookkeeper actually posted. Exhibit B already credits Accounts Receivable for the write-off, so that side needs no second entry. However, the bookkeeper debited expense instead of the allowance. To keep CPA TBS practice free of guesswork, write the recorded balances before you calculate the correction.
First show a two-step repair: reclassify the wrong write-off debit, then record the required year-end estimate. Afterward, combine those steps into one net entry as a separate equivalent method. Do not post both methods. Your response should explain why the net adjusting debit differs from the final expense for the year.
Then calculate final net receivables and the pretax income change from the actual unadjusted ledger. The requested income change compares the corrected accounts with the bookkeeper’s current expense balance. It is neither absolute net income nor the full estimate entry after you have already reversed the wrong debit.
Check the actual-ledger correction
Commit the two-step repair or equivalent net entry, final expense, net receivables, and income change.
Reveal the answer
Answer: First debit Allowance $8,000 and credit Bad-Debt Expense $8,000 to reclassify the wrong write-off debit. Then debit Bad-Debt Expense $13,000 and credit Allowance $13,000 for the estimate. Alternatively, post only the equivalent net entry: debit Bad-Debt Expense $5,000 and credit Allowance $5,000. Final annual expense is $13,000, allowance is $17,000 credit, and net receivables are $190,000. Pretax income falls $5,000 from the actual unadjusted books.
Actual allowance is $12,000 credit because the wrong write-off never reduced it, while the correctly posted recovery added $2,000. Actual expense is already $8,000. Thus, the net $5,000 adjustment takes allowance to $17,000 and expense to $13,000. Gross receivables remain $207,000. Do not repeat the existing receivable credit, cash collection, or both equivalent correction methods.
CPA TBS practice free: remove the recovery
Use an independent alternative for Task 3. Suppose the prior-year customer never pays during Year 1, so neither reinstatement nor recovery collection occurs. Keep opening balances, sales, ordinary collections, the current $8,000 write-off, and its actual wrong posting unchanged. The completed analysis still requires a $17,000 closing credit allowance.
This unchanged target is an explicit assumption. In the original case, the recovered account leaves the closing customer ledger after collection. In the alternative, it never re-enters that ledger. Therefore, both cases can have the same closing gross balance and supplied target despite different cash receipts and pre-estimate allowance movements.
Write the alternative correct pre-estimate allowance, annual estimate expense, and net correction from the actual books. Also report closing net receivables and customer cash receipts. Before opening the key, predict which outputs change by $2,000 and which stay fixed. Do not reverse the original solution as an extra entry: this scenario replaces the recovery facts.
Check the no-recovery alternative
Commit the independent no-recovery balances, estimate expense, net correction, and customer cash receipts.
Reveal the answer
Answer: Without recovery, the correct pre-estimate allowance is $2,000 credit and required annual expense is $15,000. Actual allowance is $10,000 credit and expense is $8,000, so the net correction debits Bad-Debt Expense and credits Allowance $7,000. Gross receivables remain $207,000; the $17,000 closing allowance still gives $190,000 net receivables. Customer receipts are $365,000 instead of $367,000.
Removing both recovery entries has zero combined effect on gross receivables. However, it removes the $2,000 allowance credit that otherwise reduces the estimate expense needed for the same target. Consequently, expense and the net repair each rise $2,000 while cash receipts fall $2,000. This comparison assumes the completed target stays fixed; it is not a claim that recoveries never affect estimates or net asset measurements.
Trace the correct allowance before comparing totals
The graphic follows the correct original allowance history, beginning with the opening credit. First the current write-off uses part of that balance. Next the recovery reinstatement restores a credit. Only then does the year-end expense move the reconstructed allowance to its required ending amount. The figure does not depict the bookkeeper’s incorrect expense debit.

Also check the write-off’s immediate effect before considering the estimate. Correctly reducing gross receivables and the allowance by the same amount leaves net receivables unchanged at that moment. This is different from the year-end estimate, which raises the allowance without removing a particular customer’s gross balance and therefore reduces the net asset.
By contrast, the recovery has two linked entries. Reinstatement raises gross receivables and the allowance together; collection then exchanges the reinstated receivable for cash. No sales revenue belongs in either entry. With a fixed closing target, the restored allowance credit affects the later estimate expense. Explain that sequence instead of treating recovered cash as a new sale.
Diagnose your first wrong account or balance
If gross receivables are wrong, check whether you omitted reinstatement or subtracted recovery cash twice. Next verify that ordinary collections exclude the separate recovery. A correct allowance calculation cannot repair an incomplete customer-ledger rollforward. Rebuild that first line before using a net receivable amount to assess the result.
If the allowance is wrong, trace the write-off debit and recovery credit independently. For example, subtracting both amounts treats the recovery like another loss. Meanwhile, using the untouched opening allowance ignores actual transactions during the year. A balance labeled simply “$4,000” is incomplete until you identify its credit direction and its point in the sequence.
For an entry error, compare the actual expense balance with the correct annual expense. The remaining adjustment is only their difference. Likewise, repeating the receivable credit for an already recorded write-off removes an extra customer balance. Preserve the existing correct posting and replace only its wrong offset before recording the estimate.
Repeat CPA TBS practice free of answer memory
For a fresh original retry, return to all original transactions, including the $2,000 recovery. Change only the supplied closing allowance target from $17,000 to $18,500. Keep the actual wrong write-off posting unchanged. First recompute the required estimate, the net correction from actual books, and ending net receivables without consulting the previous keys.
Then check: the correct pre-estimate allowance remains $4,000 credit, estimate expense is $14,500, and the net correction debits Bad-Debt Expense and credits Allowance $6,500. Final net receivables are $188,500. Therefore, a $1,500 higher target raises expense and the correction by $1,500 while reducing the net asset by $1,500.
For another subject, continue to the separate original TBS mini walkthrough. Its access-review evidence decisions differ from this account-history task. Choose your next practice from the first unsupported balance or entry, rather than turning three linked tasks into a broad readiness judgment.
Sources and study boundaries
General mechanics follow allowance write-offs and recoveries and OpenStax’s allowance adjustment explanation. This supplied-target exercise does not validate a complete credit-loss estimation model. Sources were checked October 27, 2026. Consult the current AICPA Blueprint resource for wider study scope. NASBA score information and the workbook’s AICPA scoring source explain why a practice percentage does not predict a scaled exam score.
